Ragnarok
2008-05-23 |  | Battle Fart or Game design?? |  |
Detailed Battle Log
XXX`s H.Galleon Destroyer attacks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s H.Galleon Destroyer was wiped out !
Ragnarok`s F.Sword Destroyer attacks XXX`s R.Sloop Frigate
XXX lost 7 R.Sloop Frigate
Ragnarok lost 4 F.Sword Destroyer in the attack
XXX`s R.Sloop Frigate attacks Ragnarok`s F.Sword Destroyer
Ragnarok lost 4 F.Sword Destroyer
XXX lost 2 R.Sloop Frigate in the attack
XXX`s M.Flysch Battleship flanks Ragnarok`s Large Strafez Fodder
Ragnarok`s Large Strafez Fodder was wiped out !
XXX`s H.Brigantine Frigate flanks Ragnarok`s Small Strafez Fodder
1 Ragnarok`s Small Strafez Fodder was captured !
Ragnarok`s Small Strafez Fodder was wiped out !
XXX`s T.Kalieum Cruiser attacks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s T.Kalieum Cruiser was wiped out !
XXX`s H.Barkentine Cruiser flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought flanks XXX`s H.Barkentine Cruiser
XXX`s H.Barkentine Cruiser was wiped out ! <----- I guess nirv hits first ship that doesn`t die?
XXX`s R.Snow Cruiser flanks Ragnarok`s F.Sword Destroyer
Ragnarok`s F.Sword Destroyer was wiped out !
XXX`s M.Chlor Cruiser flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged ! <--- Why this one live?
XXX`s Small Strafez Runner flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s R.Sloop Frigate attacks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s R.Sloop Frigate was wiped out !
XXX`s M.Flysch Battleship flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought flanks XXX`s M.Flysch Battleship
XXX`s M.Flysch Battleship was wiped out ! <--- same as with bark in 1st wave?
XXX`s H.Brigantine Frigate attacks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s H.Brigantine Frigate was wiped out !
XXX`s R.Snow Cruiser flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
Battle Results
Victory ! You have won the battle. (3 colonies won) |
|
Ragnarok
99+ day(s) ago | yea, on aggressive |
LastCrusader
99+ day(s) ago | was this a Nirva spam? o-O? |
Bobbysindustrialpat
99+ day(s) ago | No it`s not random on defense - think about it. Flanking ships can randomly wipe themsleves on the nirv or whatever, the nirv attacks whichever ship attacks it and doesn`t wipes itself first. Only the leftover stacks get the random attack |
Boyer
99+ day(s) ago | It`s completely random on attack and defense... What do you think flanking is? lol All up to the probability set within the game design :) |
Bobbysindustrialpat
99+ day(s) ago | Of course - it`s got to be that way in defense. I wonder about attack? |
Ragnarok
99+ day(s) ago | yea, but from the battle statistics logs it looks like the first ship that hits the nirvana that doesn`t kill itself in the process is directly attacked. |
Bobbysindustrialpat
99+ day(s) ago | I had a thread about this before - I thought its the top remaining stack too, for the `extra` attack.
DM says its random though.
Of course seeing the nirv hit the top stack doesn`t prove its not random, so what we need to see is the `extra` attack hitting some other ship....... |
Ragnarok
99+ day(s) ago | Here is the last bit of battle log that was "truncated"
XXX`s H.Brigantine Frigate attacks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged !
XXX`s H.Brigantine Frigate was wiped out !
XXX`s R.Snow Cruiser flanks Ragnarok`s Nirvana Dreadnought
Target damaged ! |
Ragnarok
99+ day(s) ago | Here is the fleet by the way
Ragnarok`s fleet
Nirvana Dreadnought 2 1 1
F.Sword Destroyer 10 10 0
Large Strafez Fodder 1 1 0
Small Strafez Fodder 1 1 0
XXX`s fleet
H.Galleon Destroyer 4 4 0
R.Sloop Frigate 14 14 0
M.Flysch Battleship 1 1 0
H.Brigantine Frigate 17 17 0
T.Kalieum Cruiser 2 2 0
H.Barkentine Cruiser 1 1 0
R.Snow Cruiser 1 0 1
M.Chlor Cruiser 1 0 1
Small Strafez Runner 1 0 1
Small Strafez Fodder 1 0 1
Colonies Captured
Name Type Land Size
E.5483 Desert 140
E.5467 Oceanic 23
E.7946 Oceanic 41
It seems odd to me, but if the first ship wipes out in the initial attack before the nirv can hit back, then does the nirv only attack the next ship that hits it that doesn`t die? |
