31/12/2008 · 03:50 AM
#14
You cannot reset just one ship. It`s all or nothing, and yes, losing all your RE ships could well be catastrophic to an empire. If people knew it happened and avoided giving you any ships you wanted and you were not on an explore empire, you would be the easiest target in existence. In a situation like that, you would pretty much have to cheat and battle arrange to get your ships.
Arguably, however, the admin might be able to gift 5 ships of each to the person. But here becomes the question. Since their whole shiplist is being reset, and other ships have changed since they selected their shiplist, do they get to select all new ships, or are they stuck with everything they chose from before except the ship that they are not allowed to have? That is not really fair. After all, if a change in ship classification is what is causing them to LOSE a ship, they should be able to repick every ship from scratch, no? And yet some would argue against that.
THAT is the slippery slope. The decision was made to allow empires who already possessed these ships to keep them because it was not unbalancing, rather than go to the lengthy effort of resetting shiplists and gifting empires with five of each ship that they desired to reverse engineer, especially given the debate about it.